• Main PoOP Analyses

       2012    2011    2010    2009    2008    2007    2006    2005    2004    2003    2002    2001


    Contributors



    Peter Aaron   ´08  ´09  ´10

    Richard Allen  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Ken Beck  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12 

    Kent B  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12 

    Peter Bochan  ´08 

    Tim Broun  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Paul Cangelosi  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´06  ´07  ´09  ´10  ´11

    Duncan Clark  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Damian Cleary*  ´01  ´02  ´04  ´06  ´08  ´09  ´11

    Don Cohen ´06  ´07  ´12 

    John DeLaire  ´03  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´10

    Scott Dellamore  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Kevin Falahee  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´10  ´12

    Eric Fine  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Jim Finnigan  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Emilio Gironda, Jr.  ´07  ´08  ´09 

    John Greak  ´01  ´02  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Kevin Hodgkiss  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´08 

    Michael Hodgkiss  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11

    Jamie Hosley  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11

    Mike Jurkovic  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Patrick Kennedy  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Bernadette Lange  ´11  ´12

    Rick Lange*  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´06  ´07 

    John Lefsky  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Oliver Lodge  ´07  ´08  ´09 

    Tony Lopez  ´07  ´08 ´09 ´10

    William Manley  ´09

    Jim Meyers  ´01  ´04  ´05  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Mike Miller  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Matt Nerney  ´01  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Irv Rosen  ´01  ´02  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Mark Rosen  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Raissa St. Pierre  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09 

    Jeff Schwartz  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´11 

    Andrew Stewart  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    John Stewart  ´01  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Bill Still*  ´01  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Tom Whalen  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´11  ´12 

    Dan Wilmer  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12

    Mark Zip  ´01  ´02  ´03  ´04  ´05  ´06  ´07  ´08  ´09  ´10  ´11  ´12
    PoOP Alumni
    Includes links to occasional PoOPsters who posted only before 2008
    PoOPlist - POmpous and Opinionated Persons – Being the collected musings on music and pop culture of a few wizened observers ready to bloviate…
  • Andrew Stewart Poop 07


    2007: Best Music

     

    1.Spoon/Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga
    (another edgy rock masterpiece from these indie veterans, this one’s near-perfect)
     
    1a. Neil Young/Live at Massey Hall 1971
    (“these are a few new songs I’ve been working on…”: mind-boggling acoustic soundboard set)
     
    2.Beirut/The Flying Club Cup
    (mournfully joyous orchestral pop, unique and moving; a quantum leap forward)
     
    3.Radiohead/In Rainbows
    (stripped-down and organic yet still complex – a beautiful, satisfying rock album)
     
    4.Ted Leo and the Pharmacists/Living With The Living
    (surprisingly melodic punk record fueled by anti-war anger and the need to rock, hard)
     
    5.Menomena/Friend and Foe
    (shockingly good electro-funk rock – like TV on the Radio, if they had balls instead of MFA’s)
     
    6.Revival/Horses of War
    (“My Morning Jacket meets Weezer” says Rob Barocci – and that’s about right)
     
    7.Band of Horses/Cease to Begin
    (more contemplative and mellow than before, the psych-country thing still sounds great)
     
    8.Tulsa/I Was Submerged (EP)
    (ripping, reverb-laced, southern guitar-rock debut rips off Jim James and crew – in a good way)
     
    9.The Good Life/Help Wanted Nights
    (simple, yearning alt-country love songs demand to be heard again and again; not one bad song here)
     
    10.New Pornographers/Challengers
    (underrated set with a lean, melodic sound that favors singing/songwriting over rocking)
     
    11.The Broken West/I Can’t Go On, I’ll Go On
    (big classic ‘70’s pop-rock sound – ELO meets Steve Miller – they’ve got tremendous heart)
     
    12.Elliott Smith/New Moon
    (the best posthumous double-disc B-sides collection…ever? Outstanding, timeless)
     
    13.The Shins/Wincing the Night Away
    (add Eric Johnson, synthesizers and some sedatives and it’s a wonderful new sound)
     
    14.The Besnard Lakes/The Besnard Lakes Are The Dark Horse
    (this slow-burning, moody, driving album is some kind of densely packed psych-rock genius)
     
    15.Wilco/Sky Blue Sky
    (a step down from greatness; it’s still beautifully crafted and full of killer guitar work)
     
    16.The Avett Brothers/Emotionalism
    (shambly country bluegrass sound with subversive lyrics grabs you and can’t be shaken loose)
     
    17.St. Vincent/Marry Me
    (beautiful, lustrous chamber pop that grows more enthralling with each listen)
     
    18.Blitzen Trapper/Wild Mountain Nation
    (spastic Pavement-meets-T. Rex-via-Lennon album that defies logic and wins your heart)
     
    19.Iron & Wine/The Shepherd’s Dog
    (bigger, percussion-heavy sound (mostly) works, very good though he overreaches a bit)
     
    20.The Bird and the Bee/ The Bird and the Bee
    (electronic bossa nova lounge music shouldn’t sound so good, but it does: cool, precise and excellent)
     
    21.The White Stripes/Icky Thump
    (sneaky, tough and raw – almost as good as “Elephant,” just less showy; they’ve still got it)
     
    22.Apples In Stereo/New Magnetic Wonder
    (outrageously enjoyable sugary indie-pop that just doesn’t grow old)
     
    23.Bright Eyes/Cassadaga
    (bigger, fuller sound with (a little) less self-indulgence moves him into the mainstream, and works)
     
    24.Jose Gonzalez/In Our Nature
    (true to his lo-fi sound, another set of simple acoustic tunes that stir wonder and anticipation)
     
    25.Andrew Bird/Armchair Apocrypha
    (complex, delicate musical dioramas with beautiful melodies, more intriguing each time)
     

    More Very Good Stuff

    Earlimart/Mentor Tormentor
    Foo Fighters/ Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace
    Great Lake Swimmers/Ongiara
    Albert Hammond Jr./Yours To Keep
    Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova/Once Soundtrack
    Modest Mouse/We Were Dead…
    The Mother Hips/Kiss The Crystal Flake
    Nina Nastasia and Jim White/You Follow Me
    Okkervil River/The Stage Names
    Rogue Wave/Asleep at Heaven’s Gate
    John Vanderslice/Emerald City
     

    Dig ‘Em Out!

    The Natural History/Beat Beat Heartbeat (2003)
    Holopaw/Holopaw (2003)
    Shannon McNally and Neal Casal/Ran On Pure Lightning (2003)
    Lynyrd Skynyrd/Second Helping (1974)
    Little Feat (1971)

     

    Overrated

    Animal Collective/Strawberry Jam
    Arcade Fire/Neon Bible
    Feist/The Reminder
    The National/Boxer
    Panda Bear/Person Pitch
     

    Missed in ’06

    Ox/American Lo Fi
    Sorta/Strange and Sad But True
     

    Bonus

    No new Coldplay
     

    Andrew Stewart

    Rhinebeck, NY

    Spread the PoOP!